Sunday, August 5, 2007

Canadian income trusts -- doomed or not?

I've just completed the beginning of a new section of my site on income investing -- on Canadian income trust funds.

So I just checked out the latest news, and it doesn't look good for those who've been hoping to stop the government of Canada from beginning to tax trusts in 2011:

You can read about that here:

Canadian trust fund taxation

The Conservative Party of Canada seems determined to shoot itself in the foot. It barely won the January 2006, where it promised no new taxes. So many Canadian voters feel betrayed by this broken campaign promise.

Plus, as the land of oil and natural gas in a politically stable country, Canada is well poised to benefit from the rising prices of energy, not to mention that most of these energy assets are in unstable and unfriendly places such as the Middle East, Russia and Venezuela. Of course the government knows this -- and wants to grab a big chunk of tax money.

I am sort of sympathetic to the "Why should trusts get away with not paying taxes when corporations have to" argument. My answer is that, simply, neither trusts nor corporations should have to pay taxes. It doesn't really make sense. Business structures are not people. Eliminate all double taxation. Just impose taxes on dividends received by individuals. This would make eliminate a lot of inefficiency.

Yet this is politically impossible. Liberals in Canada as well as the U.S. act like corporations themselves are evil rich people and it'd be a crime against the poor not to tax them.